Richard Birkhead

Well I got a written letter reply to my August letter, looks like it was written by a child and doesn’t answer or address the issue raised and only mentions one tax year when I raised two. It says “you have overpaid tax” the next paragraph says “on the other hand, our actual medical insurance was more….” Makes no sense and if I can be this vague when I decide what tax I pay I’m sure HMRC wouldn’t be happy, I feel HMRC doesn’t have a clue.

Thanks, so when the item is marked at "complete" it just means its been read and not that its been actioned? Should this be taking 4-5 months to deal with? Is there a mail option rather than phone as i've never actually got through?

All the guidance, including HMRC's own web site says i only need to contact them, a colleague in a similar situation completed the message on the HMRC Gateway and this was sufficient.

I pay pension contributions after tax and the pension company applies 20% tax to the payment, as I am a higher rate tax payer (40%) I should get an additional 20% tax and all the guidance says to write to HMRC. I wrote to HMRC and got no response, I then filled in the note/comment on the two affected tax years on the gateway and these were “completed” by HMRC but no response, payment or tax code change. I’ve tried phoning and given up as you get cut off before actually speaking to anyone so I also wrote again in August 2023 and still no response. I am absolutely owed by HMRC but it seems impossible to resolve and very frustrating. Is my next step an official complaint? I can’t see another route to contact.

I’ve had a similar issue, I pay pension contributions after tax and the pension company applies 20% tax to the payment. I am a higher (40%) tax payer so I wrote to HMRC and got no response, I then filled in the note/comment on the two affected tax years on the gateway and these were “completed” by HMRC but no response or payment given I’ve tried phoning and given up as you get cut off before actually speaking to anyone so I also wrote again in August and still no response. It’s very poor and I was wanting to make additional payments to my pension but won’t if getting the tax back is this difficult. Is my next step an official complaint?